Best Elliptical Machines

The LifeFitness elipticals are the best I have ever been on. Most elipticals have the footpads set where you are leaning back most of the time. That is not the case for the LifeFitness. I have beee using this eliptical for almost 3 years 3 to 4 times a week between the days I run.

I use them at the Anytime Fitness center and over the years I have seen most of them need mechanical attention or the tvs attached quit working. Right now the center is a little slow getting them fixed so I am down to only a couple that I can use for my very hard workouts. The main problem is the differences in the resistence between the machines. They are not calibrated as well as the treadmills. The other problem is the governor that won't let you go below 4:00 pace. If you do, the intensity increased until you slow down. Some machines momentarily lose resistence, the speed goes way below 4:00 pace and the resistence cranks up to the highest level. It's like doing an intense surprise fartlek workout.

It is the best machine and looks like they can go for 4 grand for a home model but I wouldn't buy one with all the problems that seem to need attention. You can go a lot of years to a fitness center for 4k and not have to worry about repairs. You may not use yours as much as they get used at a fitness center but they will eventually break down. I used a couple stairmasters for years and finally just got tired of repairing them all the time.

LifeFitness has great ellipticals. However, for the cost, you might want to look at purchasing an elliptigo. You can get a training stand to use it indoors, and you can take it outside and get a great workout if you want to.

http://www.elliptigo.com/

http://www.elliptigo.com/Stationary-Trainer_c_11.html

Look into the arc trainer. They are easier on the knees than the elliptical. I've been using one at the gym for a few months.

My price range was much lower than yours but I've been very happy with the Sole e35. I bought it based solely on it's high ratings from amazon. The cheaper models that I tried out had a stride length that felt cramped. The e35 was the only machine in my price range that felt like a Gym quality elliptical. It runs smoothly and quietly, assembly was simple, and, so far, its proved durable. I use it about 45 minutes every other day. The only negatives I can think of are that the dashboard controls/programs aren't fancy and the dashboard fan it pretty much useless.

Okay, thanks! I will look into the arc trainers.

I have seen the elliptigos, but didn't know about the stand to use them indoors! It gives me something to think about. The biggest adjustment I've had to make is not running in the woods, which I love. Perhaps if I could take an elliptigo there it would be almost like running.

The crack about the "surprise fartlek" made me laugh.

I just want to get a high quality machine and not have it break down, and not be leaning backward like the one poster said. The Nordictrak elliptical has the pedals a little more forward than I like. I tried removing the pedals and just standing on the flat bar (called the spring arm) that pedals around, but I kept breaking that bar (broke 3 of them!). When I put the pedals back on they stopped breaking--they probably spread my weight out a little more evenly (175 lbs).

Consumer Reports rates the Landice as the best, but you gotta get out your checkbook.

Thanks for the replies, it helps.

IMHO, TechnoGym equipment is far sturdier and generally better engineered than Life Fitness or Matrix. I'd go for the LED-screened version over the TFT as I suspect they're easier to maintain.

I've been on a lot of ellipticals in hotels and clubs, and last year went through the buying process myself. I would strongly suggest you find a place that sells a lot of them and get on them to try them out. Ellipticals all have different "patterns." Some are more up and down, and circular and are more like steppers. Especially the Precors. The Life Fitness ones are more elliptical and mimic running much more.

I ended up buying a Smooth, and it is very solid and nice, and a lot like the Life Fitness. If I had to do it again, I probably would have bought the Life Fitness though.

If I had all the money in the world, I'd buy this:

http://www.precor.com/en-us/home/products/amt/amt-835-with-open-stride-adaptive-motion-trainer

I've been on it at some hotels and it is a great machine.

Anyway... get on a lot of them and you'll discover what you like. For a runner, I'd look for a long stride length and one that doesn't feel like a stepper.

I bought a Smooth Fitness elliptical based off of the Consumer Reports and Amazon reviews. I think my model was the 3.6.

I have no complaints whatsoever, for $1300 (including shipping), I feel like I have a very durable machine that can rival some of the more expensive brands.

Can you buy the same machine that you might see in a gym? I don't understand why they have to have 2 different categories, commercial having no prices, etc...

I just want to buy a solid machine like I use at the club. The home ones all look cheap.

A few years ago I found some Landice commercial machines that were rebuilt to original spects. The sales page said they were $10,000 new for these commercial machines, and were selling at that time for about $4,000 rebuilt.

I notice that Landice has a lifetime warranty on residential machines, but only a 1-year or 5-year warranty on the commercial ones, so maybe the residential machines from Landice at least are similar to the commercial ones.

There is a good elliptical place about 50 miles from my house, and I'm going to make a trip. They have Smooth and landice there, so thanks for the info on the Smooths.

I know I do want one that's more like running. I was only moderately satisfied with my nordictrak so it will be nice to get one that feels a little more like running than being on a bike standing.

Thanks everyone for your posts. Everyone here has said something informative.

At the upper end of your price range, but well worth it:

http://amzn.to/TEB8LP

The best elliptical from Smooth in my opinion.

That is the model Smooth I have.

Pros: It is heavy and stable. Has a good long stride. Feels a lot like a Life Fitness model. Silent when you are using it.

Cons: The levels are too hard. I workout at 5 to 7 and strain to go to 10, and it goes up to 20. The plug in for an iPod is useless, and the computer is just so-so.

It is a good choice.

I should quickly add that this machine does not cost $3999 as the link to Amazon shows. It is $1,699 at Smooth's site, which is about what I bought it for.

Fairly easy to assemble, so don't pay them to assemble it for you.

Thank you for setting me straight on the price!

I've been think a lot about this. Can you comment on how it might compare to the Epic A32 E ($1,200 at Dick's of all places).

Here's a link:

http://www.epicfit.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/Product_-1_15252_19054_73507_207719

I am especially drawn to the 22-inch stride length, the 32-lb flywheel, and it has enough display for me. I'm old and all the fancy electronics (the display screen) don't do much for me. All I really need to see is time, distance, and possibly resistance level on the display. I may not learn how to use some of the fancier electronic functions of the display.

I like the idea of harder resistance. I use my Nordic Trak at the highest level (10) and it's not that tough. It should at least be able to simulate going up a hill on cross country skis at times.

Answer Manatee (and others): I was just hoping you could try to compare what you have with the Epic. It would be nice to not have to break the bank.

Thanks.

You get what you pay for.

I'm looking at the Smooth 8.0 LC

http://www.ellipticaltrainers.com/model/smooth-CE-80LC-elliptical.htm

Moderate price but I've seen some decent reviews. Don't want to make a mistake for this price though. Comments appreciated. Also want to use as an alternative to running, especially in the winter months

Again, I have the Smooth model. I am not familiar with the Epic. I did try out a bunch of "front drive" models, like the ones from Sole. I found them to have a fairly circular, stepper type motion. I didn't like that, but someone else might.

Regarding the Smooth, I would compare it most closely to the Life Fitness models. You should be able to find one of those to try out. If I have any real advice to give, it is to get on a bunch of them to try them out. Ellipticals all feel very different. You'll get used to whatever you buy, but as runner I think you want a long flat stride pattern. I wish the Smooth had an even longer stride length, and I am 5' 11".

The Smooth definitely gets really hard. I can't use it for any real length of time at its top setting. It has plenty of programs on it, but I just use it on the manual setting anyway. You can also get it to read a heart rate monitor, but I never do that either.

It is a solid piece of equipment. Takes up a bit of space and isn't easy to move around. That is fine for me as I have a big basement, but if you live in an apartment or have to move it up a lot of stairs, I don't know if I'd recommend it.

It's great to hear that you’ve maintained such a long-running history, but it’s unfortunate that your knees are suffering from the wear and tear. Shifting to an elliptical is a smart move to reduce impact on your joints while still staying active. Given your budget and usage needs, here are a few insights and suggestions:

fqahealthcare.com

Best Elliptical Machines

FQA HealthCare

Explore our guide to the best elliptical machines, featuring the best compact ellipticals and senior-friendly options. Find the perfect elliptical for your fitness needs.

Link:fqahealthcare.com/best-ellipticall-mac...

Landice Ellipticals

Pros:

Known for durability and quality, with a lifetime warranty on parts. These machines are built to last and can handle extensive use.

Cons:

The initial investment is high, but it could be worth it if you are looking for a long-term solution without worrying about frequent repairs or replacements.

Smooth Fitness Ellipticals

Pros:

Generally well-reviewed for being solid mid-range machines. They often come with decent warranties and have a good reputation for smooth motion and reliability.

Cons:

They might not match the build quality and durability of higher-end models like Landice. Maintenance could be more frequent over time, especially with heavy use.

Other Considerations

Precor:

Another top brand known for durability and smooth motion. Their machines are often used in gyms and can withstand heavy usage. Prices can vary but often fall within your budget.

Sole Fitness:

Offers robust machines with good warranties at a lower price point. Models like the Sole E95 are highly rated for home use.

NordicTrack Commercial Series:

These machines offer advanced features and good durability. The maintenance might be slightly higher, but they are generally reliable and come with a good warranty.

Points to Consider

Warranty and Maintenance: Look for machines that offer a comprehensive warranty. This will save you from unexpected costs in the long run.

Ergonomics and Comfort: Make sure to try out the machines if possible. The stride length, handlebar comfort, and pedal positioning should suit your body to prevent further strain.

Reviews from Runners: Since you specifically want feedback from runners, checking out forums like Runner's World or online communities dedicated to running might give you more tailored advice.

Final Thoughts

If the Landice model you’re considering truly offers a lifetime warranty and has the durability to match, it could be a worthwhile investment given your extensive usage.

However, if you are open to exploring other options, brands like Precor and Sole Fitness provide excellent alternatives that might offer similar benefits at a lower cost.

Ultimately, the best choice will depend on balancing initial cost with long-term reliability and maintenance needs. Trying out a few models in person, if possible, will give you a better sense of what feels right for your body and running style.

Good luck with your decision, and kudos for staying committed to your fitness journey!

I've been using an Octane Q37e for years now. Its built like a tank. Can probably pick one up used for a decent price. I highly doubt most users put theirs through even 10% of its useful life. Looks like they've changed the name to Q37x. A used Q37e is likely a good deal, but would be a beast to move.