At this point we should be able to cut and paste all the other threads on this, and put them under the heading "There's Nothing to See Here. It NEVER Happens (and They Never Win Anything Anyway)"
You don't need to lie to think this is wrong. I've coached several girls that could probably high jump 5 feet and run 5:25 at the same dual meet.
I coached a girl that was a sub 5 miler that also high jumped 5' 4". She scored in both events at the state meet but was nowhere close to winning either one.
Curse you, this never happens! You’re a bigot for even mentioning it!
So say most liberals. And make no mistake, liberals are the problem here. Even ones that claim, “I’m not in favor of this.” Maybe not, but they lack the courage to tell people, “No you can’t compete as something you clearly aren’t.” Liberals instead say things like, “Sex and gender are totally different. Sex matters in sport, but not anywhere else.” No one is buying that convoluted explanation.
I agree that boys should not be allowed to compete as girls.
But what do you mean by "Even the best decathletes / pentathletes can't do this."?
Looking at the top state marks (although these aren't the times from the meet), is there any male who can run a 4:19 mile (the #2 time) and high jump 6'6"?
But I'm sure there are a ton of males who can jog a 5:25 1600 and high jump 5'0". Just like this one did
I think the transgender issue is really highlighting the lack of depth in girl's athletics. 5 feet and 5:25 wins a state title? Everyone should have that capacity to jump their height. And 5:25 for a mile would qualify you for the Florida State meet in the worst division in dead F last.
The girls in the transgender student's division need to get better.
Curse you, this never happens! You’re a bigot for even mentioning it!
So say most liberals. And make no mistake, liberals are the problem here. Even ones that claim, “I’m not in favor of this.” Maybe not, but they lack the courage to tell people, “No you can’t compete as something you clearly aren’t.” Liberals instead say things like, “Sex and gender are totally different. Sex matters in sport, but not anywhere else.” No one is buying that convoluted explanation.
And this keeps happening, and will continue to.
Lack the courage? Someone blamed it all on liberals and got down voted so much. Most of liberals dont support this. You dont see them here because they talk about it elsewhere than racist running forums.