pavement88 wrote:
I know Whitni did not do a mission so this does not apply to her.
But I'm really tired of hearing all this "these guys can't run a step for two years unless their partner is handcuffed to them."
How do we know this is true or enforced? I don't trust religions and I don't trust kids between the age of 18 and 24. I broke a ton of rules/laws at that age and some folks probably thought I was a good christian kid.
At the end of the day I don't really care, I just wish I didn't have to hear about anyone's religion anymore.
I guess the only way to know this is true is to believe the plethora of people that have gone on missions that are telling you that they didn't dedicate much time to training. Having been on a mission myself, I would be surprised if someone did spend the time needed to improve aerobically during their mission.
Going on a mission is voluntary. If you don't want to follow the rules of being a missionary, you don't have to go. In other words, these athletes know that they're sacrificing sports for a couple of years, and then they don't do much more than minimal exercise during that time (30 minutes per day technically). It is true that to run, you'd need to be assigned to a companion that would also want to run. You don't have to believe that, but that's really how it goes. I mean, how else do you explain missionaries coming home out of shape and overweight? Doesn't sound like they're doing much serious training like their counterparts that don't go on missions.
Given that a mission is voluntary, athletes that do want to focus on their training can stay home. In fact, there are plenty of athletes at BYU that don't go on missions. A couple recent examples--Rory Linkletter and Connor McMillan weren't missionaries. Current runner Easton Allred hasn't gone on a mission. These guys are all still pretty good, so there may be something to good coaching and training that's working for these guys at BYU.
Final point, I 100% agree that being two years older would be an advantage if those two years are spent training. But since they're not, is there some magic that happens that trains these guys' aerobic systems in the two years that they are away? (given you believe they aren't training and don't believe BYU has some conspiracy missionary program to send kids away to train for two years in order to win championships in a non-revenue generating sport that almost no one cares about). So, Chioko getting third at age 26 seems to be a bit of an age advantage. Nur being 22 as a sophomore seems that he will have an age advantage as well over the next couple of years. It doesn't bother me personally since it's not breaking any rules, but I'm interested if that bothers you since they're older and have trained continuously since high school, unlike the BYU guys.