Another run across America underway - is it legit? Boots currently on the ground

Pro News/Info/Results Distance

Page 35 of 196

1 34 35 36 196

This thread was originally titled, "Incredible development in the $612,000 Transcon Goodge run, currently ongoing" but the new title is more descriptive. The description of the run is here.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 3:36pm EDT

re: recruiter57

I've been giving this some thought since I heard about his recent behaviour. From one where I was open minded about whether he was for real or not to one where I don't care.

Why?

What's amazing about it, really? He's massively supported and financially pressured to complete a walk across the country in a nothing special time. The one thing he isn't doing is running, apart from about a half marathon a day. This is a two month job to try and secure his position as a running influencer, so pushing on to walk 50-55 a day is hardly him entering a pantheon. People have done it at similar speeds pushing a stroller. Anyone who walks across the US has done an amazing job to be fair, but very, very few of them have this level of support. It's a touch embarrassing he's making out like he's a beast without even trying to do Pete's record. It's pretty funny that he's also got "his" record wrong by 10 days. He also sounds like a narcissistic piece of work, so maybe we should drop the whole giving a crap and let him fade into obscurity.

Oh and that NuCalm? Ha! What an idiot you'd have to be to believe in that con. I'm starting to sell eye masks and whale song through some cans for ten bucks. Any takers?

1 year ago 05/02/2023 3:40pm EDT

re: Darby

Darby wrote:
recruiter57 wrote:
So now I can't ask an honest question "does anyone know if he submitted it?" Has anyone ever run 48 marathons in 30 days? Has anyone else claimed that as a record? I don't know the answer to that. Unlike some on this feed, they aren't willing to admit when they don't know something. I am.
This might be one of the first FACTUAL statements said in this entire feed: the water was WAY TOO MUDDY when I got here. I am simply trying to defend good instead of negative opinion
Let me google it for you.
"Ricardo Abad Martínez (Tafalla, January 8, 1971) is a Spanish ultrarunner. He holds the world record for consecutive marathons run on consecutive days, 607."
But of course, he can't claim world record for 48 marathons run in a row because 607 obviously is not 48.

Where's Ricardo's Heart Rate data?? :)

I believe I saw his saying unofficial world recorder holder, no? And, only to show the ridiculousness in still having this WR debate, 607 days in a row is not the same as 48 in 30. Maybe we should all try to break the WR for the most snails on a face...I'm sure someone here could get more than 43 on their face and then they, too, can say they are a world record holder.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 3:42pm EDT

re: recruiter57

recruiter57 wrote:
Darby wrote:
Hello Recruiter57. A few questions for you.
Is it ok that Will G calls himself a world record holder on his site to promote himself while not being one?
Is it ok that Will G calls himself a "fastest Englishman" while not being one?
Is it ok that NuCalm sells rebranded binaural beats and "optional" wrist discs that are a total snake oil/placebo? Is it ok for Will G to promote a brand like this?
Runners indeed come in all shapes and sizes. So do frauds.
He is attempting to set a record. He isn't calling himself a world record holder...yet. And, from this glorious feed, many have stated the current record holder may not really be the record holder. Same goes for fastest Englishman.
Now let me say something blasphemous...Has anyone gone an dug in so deep to the stats of the "supposed" current record holders of both titles? Was this data even available? If not, how are we to know they were "pure"? Based on the standards of those slinging the mud, the irregularities in the HR prove that he is doing something fraudulent. If that is the case, then those with no data could have very well done the same or even worse. (I am sure they are fine people and I'm sure they didn't do anything wrong, but based on the standards of this hunt, it has to be stated)
I don't know much about NuCalm other than what I've seen from WillG's journey, so I can't speak to that. But, if we are going down that rabbit hole, there have been many races that have been sponsored by companies that have done terrible things over time. If we are to judge someone based on who they are sponsored by, what pandoras box are you willing to open?
You are correct, frauds do come in all shapes and sizes. But, so do honest people. Just because he isn't responding the way people would like, just because his team got angry at Will C (and his attacks on them), don't make him a fraud.

The previous record was set in a race. That's that sorted then.

He does say he's a record holder on his website. For 48 marathons in 30 days. That's not a world record.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 3:48pm EDT

re: Cover up?

The previous record was set in a race. That's that sorted then.
He does say he's a record holder on his website. For 48 marathons in 30 days. That's not a world record.

I truly don't know the answer to this question...has someone else done more than 48 marathons in 30 days?

1 year ago 05/02/2023 3:50pm EDT

re: recruiter57

recruiter57 wrote:
The Beer Miler wrote:
A) This guy has published claims that are not credible (i.e., he's a "world record holder");
B) This guy has made a claim that he is going for a "record" in this feat;
C) This guy has not been forthcoming, and has even been hostile when challenged to verify his current attempt. Technology makes it effortless to verify and document the attempt and he's refusing to implement proper protocols to verify what he's doing;
D) This guy is raising money through a third party donation site which raises serious concerns about how that money will actually be allocated.
I won't even comment on A-C because that would be beating a dead horse in my beliefs as I've made my points on those over and over again. But, I will adamantly battle on (D). How, on earth, are there "serious concerns" about how that money will be allocated? Do you know how much money has been raised on that third party site? More than $3billion! The dude is in the middle of his trek across America. What is the reason from anyone who has made a 'concerned' statement about how the money is going to be allocated...when the even isn't over yet? Basically you are saying "there must be something funny going on" before you even know. Again, 'guilty until proven innocent' is not how normal/rational human being should act. If, after the event is over, and you contact the two Cancer Research groups and find out something wacky is done, then bring it up. Don't go an accuse someone of doing something wrong...that is just rude and nasty. Will C went that route claiming he was going to report them to Scottland Yard...say what?? That is slander right there. Why can't you believe in the good in people, and IF they do something wrong THEN battle them. Have you once thought "A lot of good is coming from what Will G is doing? His donations might help FIGHT cancer"?

1. as far as I'm aware Will G is not donating anything, so it's not HIS donations

2. running to raise awareness about cancer is a bit strange idea to me. I know it's totally normal in todays society, but think about it for a second. are people not aware of cancer? really?

3. people who want to donate money to cancer research are much better doing it directly to cancer research centres of their choice. for instance,

donate.cancerresearchuk.org

Link:donate.cancerresearchuk.org/donate

4. the way Will G's fundraiser is set up, he gets to withdraw all the money first (GoFundMe takes its %%), then subtract all expenses from the trip (including the salaries for the paid crew), then he supposedly donates the rest to the charity that will also take its cut for administration. transparency = zero. it is obvious to me that is less money for actual cancer research as opposed to 3.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 3:51pm EDT

re: recruiter57

Pete Kostelnick for one. Frank Giannino for another.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 3:53pm EDT

re: recruiter57

recruiter57 wrote:
The previous record was set in a race. That's that sorted then.
He does say he's a record holder on his website. For 48 marathons in 30 days. That's not a world record.
I truly don't know the answer to this question...has someone else done more than 48 marathons in 30 days?

Just to make an example, Pete Kostelnick has run an average of 72 miles for 42 days during his transcontinental record; that is almost three marathons a day for 42 days. For sure more than 48 in 30 days.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 3:56pm EDT

re: Darby

Darby wrote:
4. the way Will G's fundraiser is set up, he gets to withdraw all the money first (GoFundMe takes its %%), then subtract all expenses from the trip (including the salaries for the paid crew), then he supposedly donates the rest to the charity that will also take its cut for administration. transparency = zero. it is obvious to me that is less money for actual cancer research as opposed to 3.

That's where my concern lies. I suspect this guy may be funding a pet project under the guise of a charitable endeavor. He may not be a charlatan, but he's definitely raised some concerns.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 3:57pm EDT

re: mid D guy

mid D guy wrote:
recruiter57 wrote:
I truly don't know the answer to this question...has someone else done more than 48 marathons in 30 days?
Just to make an example, Pete Kostelnick has run an average of 72 miles for 42 days during his transcontinental record; that is almost three marathons a day for 42 days. For sure more than 48 in 30 days.

In fact there are at least 12 runners I can name that have done over 60 marathons in 30 days.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:01pm EDT

re: The Beer Miler

The Beer Miler wrote:
Darby wrote:
4. the way Will G's fundraiser is set up, he gets to withdraw all the money first (GoFundMe takes its %%), then subtract all expenses from the trip (including the salaries for the paid crew), then he supposedly donates the rest to the charity that will also take its cut for administration. transparency = zero. it is obvious to me that is less money for actual cancer research as opposed to 3.
That's where my concern lies. I suspect this guy may be funding a pet project under the guise of a charitable endeavor. He may not be a charlatan, but he's definitely raised some concerns.

How is this any different from what the London Marathon does taking it's cut?

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:04pm EDT

re: Cover up?

Cover up? wrote:
In fact there are at least 12 runners I can name that have done over 60 marathons in 30 days.

Can you type them out to further debunk this "30 day marathon world record" claim? Pete Kostelnick is presumably one.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:05pm EDT

re: Sneakers On The Ground

Sneakers On The Ground wrote:
How is this any different from what the London Marathon does taking it's cut?

The London Marathon has oversight, you know, like a credible board of directors and stuff.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:07pm EDT

re: Sneakers On The Ground

Sneakers On The Ground wrote:

Because the London Marathon actually does what it says it is going to do, ie: put on a marathon. The whole point of this thread isn't the salaried crew or the charity money or whatever, it's been suggested that he isn't actually doing what he says he's doing. If tomorrow comes and goes and all we have is more heart rate speculation, I'll still be skeptical, but won't feel obligated to follow this thread anymore.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:07pm EDT

re: Sneakers On The Ground

Sneakers On The Ground wrote:
The Beer Miler wrote:
That's where my concern lies. I suspect this guy may be funding a pet project under the guise of a charitable endeavor. He may not be a charlatan, but he's definitely raised some concerns.
How is this any different from what the London Marathon does taking it's cut?

Great question. Quick google search shows that

"Just 25p in every pound taken by the company that runs the London Marathon is paid to charity, an investigation has revealed. Huge amounts is instead lavished on bumper salaries and 'undisclosed' running costs instead of being handed out to good causes."

That's from 2010, but you got the idea.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:08pm EDT

re: mid D guy

Well, there you go! That's pretty cool of them! So that would be more than 48 in 30

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:09pm EDT

re: Darby

Darby wrote:
Sneakers On The Ground wrote:
How is this any different from what the London Marathon does taking it's cut?
Great question. Quick google search shows that
"Just 25p in every pound taken by the company that runs the London Marathon is paid to charity, an investigation has revealed. Huge amounts is instead lavished on bumper salaries and 'undisclosed' running costs instead of being handed out to good causes."
That's from 2010, but you got the idea.

Exactly. At least Goodge is more honest about what he is doing with the money than the London Marathon execs secretly taking it fire themselves.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:12pm EDT

re: Surprise!

Surprise! wrote:
Because the London Marathon actually does what it says it is going to do, ie: put on a marathon. The whole point of this thread isn't the salaried crew or the charity money or whatever, it's been suggested that he isn't actually doing what he says he's doing. If tomorrow comes and goes and all we have is more heart rate speculation, I'll still be skeptical, but won't feel obligated to follow this thread anymore.

Actually, the London Marathon advertising is primarily charities but it pilfers most of the "donations" for itself to pay it's executives. Does the London Marathon says it does that?

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:12pm EDT

re: The Beer Miler

The Beer Miler wrote:
Cover up? wrote:
In fact there are at least 12 runners I can name that have done over 60 marathons in 30 days.
Can you type them out to further debunk this "30 day marathon world record" claim? Pete Kostelnick is presumably one.

Pete Kostelnick

Frank Giannino
Stan Cottrell
Tom Bassano
Marshall Ulrich
Tom McGrath
E. Gordon Brooks
Serge Girard
John Ball
John Lees
Marvin Swigart (a heart patient)
Stu Mittleman

That's just people who've run across America. There will be others.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:13pm EDT

re: Sneakers On The Ground

Sneakers On The Ground wrote:
Darby wrote:
Great question. Quick google search shows that
"Just 25p in every pound taken by the company that runs the London Marathon is paid to charity, an investigation has revealed. Huge amounts is instead lavished on bumper salaries and 'undisclosed' running costs instead of being handed out to good causes."
That's from 2010, but you got the idea.
Exactly. At least Goodge is more honest about what he is doing with the money than the London Marathon execs secretly taking it fire themselves.

Is he really? I'll wait for his financial report if there's one before coming to any conclusion.

1 year ago 05/02/2023 4:13pm EDT

re: The Beer Miler

The Beer Miler wrote:
The London Marathon has oversight, you know, like a credible board of directors and stuff.

What kind of "credible" board of directors and stuff at the London Marathon pilfers donations?

Page 35 of 196

1 34 35 36 196

Next Last

Reply Replying to

Username

Password

Leave the password field blank to post anonymously.

Post Preview

By posting you acknowledge that you have read and abide by our Terms and Conditions.

Remember me on this device.

Overall	/10
Comfort	/10
Cushioning	/10
Durability	/10
Appearance	/10
Value	/10

Another run across America underway - is it legit? Boots currently on the ground

Of General Interest

This thread has already been deleted.

You have been subscribed.

Review A Shoe & Win Free Shoes

Another run across America underway - is it legit? Boots currently on the ground

Jump To A Page

Follow recruiter57

Block recruiter57

Follow recruiter57

Block recruiter57

Follow Darby

Block Darby

Follow mid D guy

Block mid D guy

Follow The Beer Miler

Block The Beer Miler

Follow The Beer Miler

Block The Beer Miler

Follow The Beer Miler

Block The Beer Miler

Follow Surprise!

Block Surprise!

Follow Darby

Block Darby

Follow recruiter57

Block recruiter57

Follow Darby

Block Darby

Jump To A Page

Of General Interest

This thread has already been deleted.

Reply Replying to

You have been subscribed.

Help Contribute to a Better Running Shoe Site

Review A Shoe & Win Free Shoes