"Whether you think pull or think push, you are performing a 'whole body action' that is far more than just the pull or push you are thinking of"
----------------------------------------------------------
Yes, but the prime movers shift significantly. For example, do a drill: stand with both feet on the ground, have someone place his hand on your knee, and lift the foot under your hip, while the hand presses your knee down. Now - do the same, but ask someone to hold you by the heel and pull it down while you lift the foot under your hip. Feel the difference? Meanwhile you are performing the same movement - raising the foot up to your hip.
-----------------------------------------------------------
"For some people using the conscious cue of focusing on the pulling aspect might help them get the action optimal."
-----------------------------------------------------------
At least for me it was a huge break-through. I remember 20 years of running I had the feeling of struggling against the ground, with Pose it is gone.
-----------------------------------------------------------
"I don't agree with the POSE one-size-fits-all approach saying that focusing on the pull is the only way to arrive at the correct action"
----------------------------------------------------------
Of course you are free not to agree. I see one-size-fits-all approach as a huge plus, because it enables to work all components into one system of teaching. Let me give an example: when a coach in karate or boxing teaches you to perform a correct sraight blow with the rear hand, he tells you that the motion should start with turning your rear heel a bit, then the turning motion is continued by your hips, then the trunk, the last is the shoulder - all this makes your hand "fly" forward as if by itself, without even engaging arm muscles. Now someone can say that it's better to start, let's say, with opening your mouth, then closing your eyes and sticking your ass back - and I have no problem with it, if it allows you to perform a sharp, quick and strong blow. But this other teaching technique should also be worked into a system, because a system is more than the sum of its components - you change one thing, and all the rest falls apart. That's why I'm in favor of orthodox Pose.
-----------------------------------------------------------
"For me running, yes, not focusing on the landing is helpful, but i focus on the drive rather than the pull"
--------------------------------------------------------
Please, explain your understanding of "drive", to avoid confusion.
--------------------------------------------------------
"Its not a main point here, but why does a more rigid landing lead to more time on support - i don't see any definate cause-effect relationship."
---------------------------------------------------------
"Rigid landing" means more how the foot is planted physically, I would rather use the term "active landing" since it puts more emphasize on HOW THE ACTION IS PERFORMED. Active landing is unncessary movement involvement: the foot should drop to the ground by gravity with no additional muscle work, this enables you to pick the foot of the ground as soon as it is physically possible ( the moment when you get unbalanced and the support foot is unloaded). If you perform the movement as if pushing the ground back from under yourself, means you are involving antagonist muscles than the ones you use to pick the foot up, that means you have two actions that can't be executed simultaneously, one must preceed the other - hence longer time on support. Besides, active landing in most cases is reaching out with the foot, means you have a good chance to be landing in front ( and landing in front means braking, thus longer time on support). This is especially visible when you are tired and try to accelerate - the faster you want to run, the bigger range of motion you execute, and the less efficient you are ( because range of motion has nothing to do with stride length). Pose teaches not to lose compact stride regardless of effort level.
-----------------------------------------------------------
"Landing with quiet feet - as in making little sound - i agree is entirely desirable."
----------------------------------------------------------
This is what Pose calls "quiet feet". But making little sound is the result, if you concentrate on running with the least possible sound, you'll end up running on you toes like a ballet dancer, reaching forward with your toes - it's quite incorrect.
---------------------------------------------------------
"The runner who over-activates landing 'jams', the runner who under-activates 'collapses'. Get it right and you 'spring'."
--------------------------------------------------------
You should "spring", but shouldn't consciously push off (according to Pose, of course).
---------------------------------------------------------
"The motor impulses associated with the pre-activation arise as a result of activity in higher brain centres - you are anticipating foot-ground contact, reflexes do not anticipate."
---------------------------------------------------------
Yes, but anticipation is one thing (it's PRIOR to landing), and what happens after ground contact is a reflex to a great extent (of course, it by no means can be confined to pure reflexes). This all makes a complex whole-body response, which can be dissected to and fro for scientific purposes, but for practical reasons I think it's good to use the good old term "recoil": in practice all the complexities can be divided into: 1. What we give command to execute. 2. What happens by itself. So Pose tells us that if something can happen by itself - don't MAKE it happen, because it will happen nevertheless.
----------------------------------------------------------
"I probably focus on knee lift more than POSE advocates. I then simply CONTROL the limb's forward motion using my muscles to prevent over-striding"
-----------------------------------------------------------
From Pose standpoint you are doing too much work. A Pose coach would tell you - lean forward and move your limbs so that they don't get in your way. From Pose standpoint, you should try to use your muscles to get from pose to pose, and not to propel you forward.( I guess again I openend a can of worms with this statement, LOL).
----------------------------------------------------------
"Knee lift does not NECESSARILY lead to over-striding"
---------------------------------------------------------
It may not at lower effort levels, but when one does that final kick at 5000 m, it more often than not does.
-----------------------------------------------------------
"My aim is not the contradict POSE or prove it wrong at every turn."
----------------------------------------------------------
Hahaha! Means you admit that you are off the topic - since it is about whether Pose is crazy or not? I'm glad that after writing 33 pages we started discussing, LOL.