1.) "No one knows the source of the nandrolone for sure, except possibly Shelby, who was unable to prove it." She provided a defense on how it got in there so this is what we go off of. Furthermore, she and her coaches were deceptive in their explanation. (Claiming she got it from a pork burrito and obfuscating the fact she order a steak burrito).
2.) "Whatever you think “trace” means, the quantity was a small amount, larger than what usually occurs naturally, but entirely within the limits of and consistent with ingestion of food rich in nandrolone." The amount was 3x what she would have gotten if it came from an offal burrito (again, she claimed pork and the receipt showed steak). This is not what she claimed she ate, and was proven that the offal that the food truck served was stomach muscle meat, NOT the organ meat that would have triggered the test. Impossible that the protein would have been "rich in nandrolone."
2.1 She did not claim to have that supplements "triggered" the test, so we cannot therefore assume that's where they came from. And people seem to conveniently forget that if they did come from them, THAT'S STILL A BAN.
3.) "Given the small quantity found, two of the most likely sources of nandrolone remain accidental ingestion by the edible parts of soy-fed intact boar, or possibly contamination of supplements (banned or unbanned)." This mythcial "soy fed intact boar" literally does not exist in the American meat supply. Also, the meat was sourced to factory in which is what harvested, and they showed that the practices that would have resulted your fantastical beast were not used.
4.) "Neither the AIU, nor the CAS disproved, or gave evidence disproving, intact boar consumption by burrito." The burden is on SHELBY to prove this, not AIU/CAS. Again, THE MEAT FROM THE FOOD TRUCK WAS SOURCED and the did show that the factory the meat came from weren't "soy fed."
5.) "Houlihan was put in the impossible situation of not being able to test the burrito, or some batches of supplements, to prove, or rule-out, these possibilities." Again, the meat was sourced and was shown that it couldn't have had natural nandrolone in it. Also, SHE HAS NO PROFF SHE ATE PORK. She has proof she ate a steak burrito!
6.) "There is no evidence that Houlihan consumed any artificial nandrolone supplements as suggested by the conflicted WADA lab director/AIU expert, giving a similar “entirely within the limits of and consistent with ingestion” argument."
These are literally cut/copied from the ruling -
"Prof Ayotte explains that nor-DHEA is a chemical/exogenous 19-NA prohormone which is found in norsteroid products and, when used orally, produces pseudo-endogenous results in urine analysis. According to her studies, the carbon isotopic signature of oral supplements of nandrolone precursors, such as nor-DHEA, possess “pseudoendogenous” carbon isotopic signature at -23‰ – similar to the one reported in the Athlete’s samples." (pg. 22)
"The analytical result is consistent with the consumption of a norsteroid oral supplement that has the same carbon isotopic signature as was reported in the Athlete’s samples." (p. 37)
7.) "Using the logic presented to the CAS, no one wins the lottery or gets struck by lightning, or bowls 300, or spontaneously combusts. It is easy to fall for this prosecutor’s fallacy, especially if you want to believe it." The amount of evidence against her in the ruling is so overwhelming that her defense actually being true would have been akin to winning the lottery.
8.) "It’s possible that Shelby lied to the public, her competitors, her teammates/coach, but highly unlikely." From the gun they were being deceptive to the public AT BEST. She, Jerry, and Shalane claimed she tested positive after eating a pork burrito despite have no evidence and hiding the fact until later that she actually ordered and had a receipt for a steak burrito. They then went scorched Earth on WADA and the AIU and haven't shown any hint contrition, provided an apology, or even acknowledged their deceitfulness since then.
Someone should check this poster's IP address to see if it's coming from Beaverton.