I have followed or personally watched most of these boys run over the past 2 years. Based on the indoor times from past sub 4 HS milers there truly are 10 or more boys who could POTENTIALLY run sub 4. But most likely only 3 or 4 will—High School track seasons are not set up to support optimum peak performance. My guess is Colin, Martin, Harrison and one wildcard will finish sub 4–but many more could if that were their primary goal.
1. Weather and timing are key. I truly believe that anyone who ran sub 4:05 Indoor this year could potentially run 3:59.99 in PERFECT race conditions outdoor.
2. the problem is scheduling/timing. Most of these boys have ‘team’ responsibilities to prioritize. Invites, sectionals, regionals, state championships…running every weekend in multiple events is not conducive to training for and peaking for a 3:59.
3. The national meets are not conducive to running fast mid/long distance times—they are designed as marketing platforms and money makers. Yes the national meets often cover costs for the top athletes to attend (in order to lure every other paying customer who can now enter the Emerging Elite, Freshman Race, Junior High Race, and who knows what new relay event…) But these Championship mid/distance races tend to be run at 4:00 PM in full sun and 90 degree heat with only a few of the actual top runners present.
4. IMO If we really wanted to see 10 kids potentially challenge for sub 4 we should organize a race the last week of June, to be run at dusk at Stanford (or another mild climate, low humidity, fast track location). This gives them the chance to recover slightly from a busy May racing season and we are 90% assured that the weather and field of runners would be ideal. But unfortunately this will never happen because the HS Seniors will feel the need to begin their XC training base in June to prepare for college….
So we will probably never know just how many of these kids could have done it. But considering 9 of the top 20 All-Time indoor HS miles on MileSplit were run this year, I’d say this is a special class regardless of how many end up doing it.